{ "schema_version": "1.0.0", "claim_registry": "data/trust/claim_registry.json", "defaults": { "open_rationale": "No protected adjudication evidence is registered; the critique remains open under the response timeline policy (Critical <= 14 days, High <= 30 days, Medium <= 60 days, Low <= 90 days).", "open_uncertainty": "The critique has not completed evidence-backed adjudication.", "open_falsifier": "A protected, reproducible result may refute or materially narrow the critique.", "open_next_gate": "Register evidence, review the affected pages, and merge an adjudication through protected review according to severity response SLA (Critical <= 14 days, High <= 30 days, Medium <= 60 days, Low <= 90 days)." }, "critiques": [ { "critique_id": "crit-muscle-physiology", "source_path": "critiques/01_muscle_physiology.md", "severity": "high", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": ["articles/affine-nature-golf-swing.qmd"], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-aerodynamics", "source_path": "critiques/02_aerodynamics.md", "severity": "medium", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": ["articles/affine-nature-golf-swing.qmd"], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-neuromuscular-control", "source_path": "critiques/03_neuromuscular_control.md", "severity": "high", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": ["articles/affine-nature-golf-swing.qmd"], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-impact-evasion", "source_path": "critiques/04_impact_evasion.md", "severity": "medium", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": ["articles/affine-nature-golf-swing.qmd"], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-control-causality-mechanical", "source_path": "critiques/control_causality_vs_mechanical.md", "severity": "high", "disposition": "responded", "affected_pages": [ "articles/affine-nature-golf-swing.qmd", "articles/proximal-distal-energy-transfer.qmd" ], "related_claim_ids": [], "adjudication": { "rationale": "The canonical theory now treats algebraic attribution as conditional on the declared model, coordinates, parameters, intervention, horizon, and identifiability evidence, and blocks inference of neural intent or unique real-world cause.", "evidence_paths": [ "tests/test_control_affine_scientific_trust.py", "articles/affine-nature-golf-swing.qmd" ], "verification_commit": "bb50862bd9993f5101bd9da71ee9a78f124cfb6e", "verified_on": "2026-08-29", "reviewer": "protected AffineDrift review", "falsifier": "A maintained canonical page again infers intent, individual-muscle force, biological effort, or unique cause from the affine decomposition alone.", "uncertainty": "The correction is a publication-scope adjudication, not biological validation of the model.", "next_gate": "Acquire intervention-specific human evidence capable of separating passive, reflexive, and voluntary contributions." }, "history": [ { "from": "open", "to": "responded", "on": "2026-08-29", "commit": "bb50862bd9993f5101bd9da71ee9a78f124cfb6e", "rationale": "Protected PR #4046 added the model- and intervention-conditioned attribution boundary." } ] }, { "critique_id": "crit-coulomb-friction-violation", "source_path": "critiques/coulomb_friction_violation.md", "severity": "medium", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": ["articles/theory-part3.qmd"], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-dimensional-inconsistency-dcr", "source_path": "critiques/dimensional_inconsistency_dcr.md", "severity": "high", "disposition": "responded", "affected_pages": ["articles/drift-control-ratio.qmd"], "related_claim_ids": ["ad-dcr-001"], "adjudication": { "rationale": "The DCR article now defines a declared acceleration-space magnitude ratio and separates it from finite-horizon reachability, path-correction authority, and impact outcome.", "evidence_paths": [ "tests/test_dcr_reachability_contract.py", "src/affine_control/reachability.py", "articles/drift-control-ratio.qmd" ], "verification_commit": "524c28926f364631ed06b15be9c6fdf440acce64", "verified_on": "2026-08-28", "reviewer": "protected AffineDrift review", "falsifier": "The maintained DCR definition again mixes state-rate units or treats the scalar as a reachability certificate.", "uncertainty": "The response does not quantify model-form, input-set, coordinate, norm, parameter, or measurement uncertainty.", "next_gate": "Run declared finite-horizon three-dimensional perturbation studies with uncertainty and impact outcomes." }, "history": [ { "from": "open", "to": "responded", "on": "2026-08-28", "commit": "524c28926f364631ed06b15be9c6fdf440acce64", "rationale": "Protected PR #4044 corrected the DCR definition and added an executable reachability counterexample." } ] }, { "critique_id": "crit-double-pendulum-energy-blindness", "source_path": "critiques/double_pendulum_energy_blindness.md", "severity": "medium", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": [ "articles/drift-components-wrench-double-pendulum.qmd" ], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-drift-superposition", "source_path": "critiques/drift_superposition.md", "severity": "medium", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": ["articles/affine-nature-golf-swing.qmd"], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-flaccid-drift-contradiction", "source_path": "critiques/flaccid_drift_contradiction.md", "severity": "high", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": [ "articles/theory-part1.qmd", "articles/theory-part5.qmd" ], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-geometric-stiffness-omission", "source_path": "critiques/geometric_stiffness_omission.md", "severity": "medium", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": ["articles/affine-nature-golf-swing.qmd"], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-hard-constraint-fallacy", "source_path": "critiques/hard_constraint_fallacy.md", "severity": "high", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": ["articles/wrist-universal-joint.qmd"], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-input-dependent-boundary-conditions", "source_path": "critiques/input_dependent_boundary_conditions.md", "severity": "high", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": [ "articles/affine-nature-golf-swing.qmd", "articles/theory-part4.qmd" ], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-intentional-constraint-collapse", "source_path": "critiques/intentional_constraint_collapse.md", "severity": "high", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": ["articles/intentional-constraint-collapse.qmd"], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-intermediate-axis-fallacy", "source_path": "critiques/intermediate_axis_fallacy.md", "severity": "high", "disposition": "responded", "affected_pages": ["articles/secondary-axis-stability.qmd"], "related_claim_ids": [], "adjudication": { "rationale": "The full article and both critiques now separate torque-free perturbations, supported dynamics, gravity and impulse response. Independent manufactured tests check the corrected rates, origins, units and comparison conditions; unsupported equipment and physiological claims are withdrawn.", "evidence_paths": [ "articles/secondary-axis-stability.qmd", "critiques/intermediate_axis_fallacy.md", "tests/test_secondary_axis_rigor.py" ], "verification_commit": "834b3145deb576e5489e313c8b96cb64a6cde8cc", "verified_on": "2026-09-27", "reviewer": "Codex technical review for #4467; protected merge required", "falsifier": "The text reintroduces unsupported equipment superiority, omits forced/support terms, or its manufactured algebra checks fail.", "uncertainty": "No equipment geometry, measured stroke, participant or physiological dataset establishes superiority or a dominant mechanism.", "next_gate": "Any future equipment-benefit claim requires a declared forced model and comparative delivery/impact measurements with uncertainty." }, "history": [ { "from": "open", "to": "responded", "on": "2026-09-27", "commit": "834b3145deb576e5489e313c8b96cb64a6cde8cc", "rationale": "The full article and both critiques now separate torque-free perturbations, supported dynamics, gravity and impulse response. Independent manufactured tests check the corrected rates, origins, units and comparison conditions; unsupported equipment and physiological claims are withdrawn." } ] }, { "critique_id": "crit-lie-bracket-formalism-overreach", "source_path": "critiques/lie_bracket_formalism_overreach.md", "severity": "high", "disposition": "responded", "affected_pages": ["articles/drift-control-ratio.qmd"], "related_claim_ids": ["ad-dcr-001"], "adjudication": { "rationale": "The DCR article excises claims of continuous dimension collapse under drift, distinguishes acceleration actuation rank from full-state controllability, and bounds reachable sets under declared inputs.", "evidence_paths": [ "tests/test_dcr_reachability_contract.py", "tests/test_dcr_article_rigor.py", "articles/drift-control-ratio.qmd" ], "verification_commit": "06ad67134fb08841281640d4373d9df1d7cc56ae", "verified_on": "2026-09-10", "reviewer": "protected AffineDrift review", "falsifier": "The maintained text reintroduces dimension-collapse claims or treats instantaneous input rank as state controllability.", "uncertainty": "The response does not compute global reachable sets for spatial underactuated models.", "next_gate": "Run declared finite-horizon three-dimensional perturbation studies with uncertainty and impact outcomes." }, "history": [ { "from": "open", "to": "responded", "on": "2026-09-10", "commit": "06ad67134fb08841281640d4373d9df1d7cc56ae", "rationale": "Protected PR #4339 corrected DCR Lie bracket claims, actuation rank distinctions, and reachability boundaries." } ] }, { "critique_id": "crit-misattribution-stability-gravity", "source_path": "critiques/misattribution_of_stability_gravity.md", "severity": "high", "disposition": "responded", "affected_pages": ["articles/secondary-axis-stability.qmd"], "related_claim_ids": [], "adjudication": { "rationale": "The full article and both critiques now separate torque-free perturbations, supported dynamics, gravity and impulse response. Independent manufactured tests check the corrected rates, origins, units and comparison conditions; unsupported equipment and physiological claims are withdrawn.", "evidence_paths": [ "articles/secondary-axis-stability.qmd", "critiques/misattribution_of_stability_gravity.md", "tests/test_secondary_axis_rigor.py" ], "verification_commit": "834b3145deb576e5489e313c8b96cb64a6cde8cc", "verified_on": "2026-09-27", "reviewer": "Codex technical review for #4467; protected merge required", "falsifier": "The text reintroduces unsupported equipment superiority, omits forced/support terms, or its manufactured algebra checks fail.", "uncertainty": "No equipment geometry, measured stroke, participant or physiological dataset establishes superiority or a dominant mechanism.", "next_gate": "Any future equipment-benefit claim requires a declared forced model and comparative delivery/impact measurements with uncertainty." }, "history": [ { "from": "open", "to": "responded", "on": "2026-09-27", "commit": "834b3145deb576e5489e313c8b96cb64a6cde8cc", "rationale": "The full article and both critiques now separate torque-free perturbations, supported dynamics, gravity and impulse response. Independent manufactured tests check the corrected rates, origins, units and comparison conditions; unsupported equipment and physiological claims are withdrawn." } ] }, { "critique_id": "crit-normative-ambiguity-drift", "source_path": "critiques/normative_ambiguity_drift.md", "severity": "medium", "disposition": "responded", "affected_pages": [ "articles/drift-control-ratio.qmd", "articles/theory-part1.qmd" ], "related_claim_ids": ["ad-dcr-001"], "adjudication": { "rationale": "The canonical theory removes normative claims that high drift constitutes motor failure or passenger status, treating DCR strictly as a descriptive acceleration ratio without conflating vector alignment with free energy or psychological flow.", "evidence_paths": [ "tests/test_dcr_reachability_contract.py", "tests/test_dcr_article_rigor.py", "articles/drift-control-ratio.qmd" ], "verification_commit": "06ad67134fb08841281640d4373d9df1d7cc56ae", "verified_on": "2026-09-10", "reviewer": "protected AffineDrift review", "falsifier": "The maintained text reintroduces normative claims equating passive drift with motor failure or ungrounded psychological flow states.", "uncertainty": "The response does not model biological motor coordination or neuromuscular objective functions.", "next_gate": "Run declared finite-horizon three-dimensional perturbation studies with uncertainty and impact outcomes." }, "history": [ { "from": "open", "to": "responded", "on": "2026-09-10", "commit": "06ad67134fb08841281640d4373d9df1d7cc56ae", "rationale": "Protected PR #4339 removed normative drift interpretations and framed DCR as an unvalidated geometric scalar." } ] }, { "critique_id": "crit-nullspace-interpretation", "source_path": "critiques/nullspace_interpretation.md", "severity": "high", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": ["articles/affine-nature-golf-swing.qmd"], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-parameter-causality-leakage", "source_path": "critiques/parameter_causality_leakage.md", "severity": "medium", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": ["articles/affine-nature-golf-swing.qmd"], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-passive-active-boundary-ambiguity", "source_path": "critiques/passive_active_boundary_ambiguity.md", "severity": "medium", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": ["articles/affine-nature-golf-swing.qmd"], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-passive-overshoot-artifact", "source_path": "critiques/passive_overshoot_artifact.md", "severity": "medium", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": [ "articles/affine-nature-golf-swing.qmd", "articles/zero-torque-counterfactual.qmd", "articles/theory-part2.qmd" ], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-planar-dcr-blindness", "source_path": "critiques/planar_dcr_blindness.md", "severity": "high", "disposition": "responded", "affected_pages": ["articles/drift-control-ratio.qmd"], "related_claim_ids": ["ad-dcr-001"], "adjudication": { "rationale": "The canonical article scopes DCR derivations strictly to declared planar coordinates and manufactured mechanical cases, rejecting unvalidated extensions to 3D clubface orientation while noting that 3D dynamics couple planar velocities to off-plane axes.", "evidence_paths": [ "tests/test_dcr_reachability_contract.py", "tests/test_dcr_article_rigor.py", "articles/drift-control-ratio.qmd" ], "verification_commit": "06ad67134fb08841281640d4373d9df1d7cc56ae", "verified_on": "2026-09-10", "reviewer": "protected AffineDrift review", "falsifier": "The maintained text reasserts planar DCR as a proxy for 3D clubface closure or asserts uncoupled axial dynamics without evidence.", "uncertainty": "The response does not solve full spatial 3D multibody reachability under musculoskeletal actuation.", "next_gate": "Run declared finite-horizon three-dimensional perturbation studies with uncertainty and impact outcomes." }, "history": [ { "from": "open", "to": "responded", "on": "2026-09-10", "commit": "06ad67134fb08841281640d4373d9df1d7cc56ae", "rationale": "Protected PR #4339 scoped DCR to declared planar models and excised unverified 3D clubface variance claims." } ] }, { "critique_id": "crit-precision-gross-control", "source_path": "critiques/precision_vs_gross_control.md", "severity": "high", "disposition": "responded", "affected_pages": ["articles/drift-control-ratio.qmd"], "related_claim_ids": ["ad-dcr-001"], "adjudication": { "rationale": "The canonical article withdraws claims that late downswing is locked into a ballistic trajectory with no meaningful correction possible, while clarifying that DCR does not equate to velocity percentages or bypass transversality in event-time sensitivities.", "evidence_paths": [ "tests/test_dcr_reachability_contract.py", "tests/test_dcr_article_rigor.py", "articles/drift-control-ratio.qmd" ], "verification_commit": "06ad67134fb08841281640d4373d9df1d7cc56ae", "verified_on": "2026-09-10", "reviewer": "protected AffineDrift review", "falsifier": "The maintained text claims high DCR locks the trajectory or derives ball dispersion directly from scalar acceleration ratios.", "uncertainty": "The response does not establish empirical feedback correction thresholds for human golfers in late downswing.", "next_gate": "Run declared finite-horizon three-dimensional perturbation studies with uncertainty and impact outcomes." }, "history": [ { "from": "open", "to": "responded", "on": "2026-09-10", "commit": "06ad67134fb08841281640d4373d9df1d7cc56ae", "rationale": "Protected PR #4339 removed locked-in trajectory claims and distinguished scalar ratios from event sensitivities." } ] }, { "critique_id": "crit-sequencing-lie-bracket-fallacy", "source_path": "critiques/sequencing_lie_bracket_fallacy.md", "severity": "medium", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": [ "articles/nonlinear-control-insights.qmd", "articles/proximal-distal-energy-transfer.qmd" ], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-simulation-tautology", "source_path": "critiques/simulation_tautology.md", "severity": "medium", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": [ "articles/theory-part5.qmd", "articles/affine-nature-golf-swing.qmd", "articles/proximal-distal-energy-transfer.qmd" ], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-static-fallacy-zvcf", "source_path": "critiques/static_fallacy_zvcf.md", "severity": "medium", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": [ "articles/affine-nature-golf-swing.qmd", "articles/zero-torque-counterfactual.qmd", "articles/theory-part2.qmd" ], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-stiffness-pulse-paradox", "source_path": "critiques/stiffness_pulse_paradox.md", "severity": "high", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": [ "articles/intentional-constraint-collapse.qmd", "articles/theory-part3.qmd", "articles/proximal-distal-energy-transfer.qmd" ], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-stretch-shortening-blindspot", "source_path": "critiques/stretch_shortening_blindspot.md", "severity": "high", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": [ "articles/theory-part1.qmd", "articles/affine-nature-golf-swing.qmd" ], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-strokes-gained-non-ergodic", "source_path": "critiques/strokes_gained_non_ergodic.md", "severity": "medium", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": ["articles/strokes-gained-limitations.qmd"], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-teleological-blindness", "source_path": "critiques/teleological_blindness.md", "severity": "medium", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": ["articles/affine-nature-golf-swing.qmd"], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-effective-plant-fallacy", "source_path": "critiques/the_effective_plant_fallacy.md", "severity": "high", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": [ "articles/theory-part3.qmd", "articles/affine-nature-golf-swing.qmd", "articles/proximal-distal-energy-transfer.qmd" ], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-tip-mass-omission", "source_path": "critiques/tip_mass_omission.md", "severity": "critical", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": ["articles/theory-part1.qmd"], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-validation-dimensionality-gap", "source_path": "critiques/validation_dimensionality_gap.md", "severity": "high", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": [ "articles/theory-part5.qmd", "articles/wrist-universal-joint.qmd" ], "related_claim_ids": [] }, { "critique_id": "crit-ztcf-identifiability", "source_path": "critiques/ztcf_identifiability.md", "severity": "high", "disposition": "open", "affected_pages": [ "articles/affine-nature-golf-swing.qmd", "articles/zero-torque-counterfactual.qmd", "articles/theory-part2.qmd", "articles/proximal-distal-energy-transfer.qmd" ], "related_claim_ids": [] } ] }